1. Well growing up as a fan of the Spiderman animated series in the 90's, I liked the Black cat's charm and if that same type of character role is to be in the movie I would say that Rachel McAdams would be a good pick but more so as the Felicia Hardy aspect side that flirts with Peter Parker. But since that was just rumors I wouldn't mind Julia Stiles as the role but definitely not Anne Hathaway, though I do like Anne she just doesn't fit the role in my eyes.

Also I saw in some of the other comments for previous news on the Black Cat, a few of the commentors kind of got the idea that Black Cat is no different from Cat woman, but there definitely is a difference between the 2, to sum it up I would say Cat woman is more a villain and Black Cat is an Ally to spiderman with the occasional going against him solely for her personal issues (pertaining to her relationship with Morpheus and issues with her Father).

But hopefully the director makes a good pick.

Posted at 10:41PM on Nov 18th 2009 by Oblique

2. She's waaaaaay too tall for Maguire! Shouldn't that matter?

Posted at 11:19PM on Nov 18th 2009 by DAVID F

3. Oh, I actually think that would work for the dynamic.

Posted at 7:40PM on Nov 22nd 2009 by Dorv

4. Sounds good to me. She definitely has the physique to fill the role. Plus she has legitimate acting chops which is always a good thing. Julie Stiles? No thanks. She has no charisma. Rachel McAdams would have been a good choice, but Anne Hathaway has the body for it.

Posted at 11:29PM on Nov 18th 2009 by Creep

5. Hathaway is a great choice to give ol' Spidey a run for his money, so to speak.

Posted at 12:16PM on Nov 19th 2009 by Thomas

6. I can see Hathaway as Black Cat more then I can see Julia Stiles. Granted I haven't seen a Julia Stiles film in awhile. I know we're getting more into phyical attributes. What woman has them and what woman doesn't. And I know the movies haven't really been about that. Kristen Dunst certainly doesn't have the physical features Mary Jane has. Yet I can see Anne's Black Cat being that flirtatious Felicia w/ Peter Parker. I think it was wrong for them to have made Gwen Stacy a character in the third movie. She was reduced to a girl with a crush when in the comics she was so much more. She was Peter's first love. Again I'm worried that too many characters may bog down the movie unnecessairly.

Posted at 2:53AM on Nov 19th 2009 by Midnight13

7. I could see either one handling the role, but I think Hathaway would be the better fit. However, I have a hard time seeing her taking the part. I know a lot of celebrities these days are jumping into the comic book movie scene, but she doesn't strike me as the type that would be very interested. Feel free to prove me wrong Anne!

Posted at 8:42AM on Nov 19th 2009 by Wexler

8. Oh wow, Julia Styles really? Well she does what the flattened cat face I guess.

Posted at 9:03AM on Nov 19th 2009 by Eric H

9. Hathaway would be an amazing choice! The mere thought of Stiles doing it over Hathaway makes me throw up in my mouth a little bit.

Posted at 12:22PM on Nov 19th 2009 by Bundy

10. well, since they can't travel back in time and get Kelly Preston circa 1985 into that suit ...

Anne Hathaway is a perfect acceptable substitute.

Posted at 12:59PM on Nov 19th 2009 by justin

11. I can't believe most of you guys think Anne is a good choice for the Black cat, I mean she's a very good actress and all. But she in no way fits this roll. Plus when the black cat is in her normal life Felicia Hardy role herhair is blonde and Anne wouldn't look great as a blonde. The Black cat/ Felicia Hardy role is more so like a Kate Hudson, she is a flirt towards Peter Parker with big charisma. Anne to me would just look like a nerd in a suit. But this is supposed to be Spiderman 4 so I guess for all you 'Great' fans of spiderman3 will just love Anne in this one. If she is the black cat call me when marvel gets their rights back from sony and the series gets rebooted.

Posted at 1:29PM on Nov 19th 2009 by Blake

12. I'd have preferred McAdams; she could've filled out that catsuit...

But, hey, it's not Megan Fox. That's fine with me.

Posted at 7:12PM on Nov 19th 2009 by Tor

13. Hathaway would be a great choice. She has the looks and she can be really flirtatuous. Also, she is really misterious when she wants. Besides, she's a great actress.
I can't imagine Stiles getting the role. McAdams would be more acceptable.
But Hathaway is nearly perfect for the role.

Posted at 2:26PM on Dec 15th 2009 by Torah

14. Anne Hathaway makes me want to eat glass. I won't even go see the next Spiderman if she's in it. It's not even her acting, it's her nerdy wanna-be hot girl looks. Rachel McAdams is ten thousand times hotter.

Posted at 11:45PM on Jan 1st 2010 by Ross